Greenbergs fianc, Sam Goldberg, told investigators that he left for the gym while Ellen was chopping up fruit in the kitchen. Medical examiner Marlon Osbourne, however, determined her death to be a homicide before reversing course and amending the ruling to suicide more than a month later, according to the lawsuit. "I didn't think it seemed genuine at all.". Her parents have been fighting for over a decade to have the manner changed to undecided or homicide. That was more than a year ago. For Greenberg's parents, that conclusion never sat right. She didnt leave behind a note. Chester County prosecutors confirmed they have assigned a prosecutor and detective to Greenbergs case. I found this article, which answered a lot of my questions like: Ellen Greenberg was killed on Jan. 26, 2011 and Sam Goldberg married Caroline Schnay in early January 2014, just 3 years later, when Sam was 31 and Caroline was 32. I dont understand how they wrote this off as a suicide., Wechts January 2012 report labeled it strongly suspicious of homicide.. (Fox News). 'Teacher Death Mystery': Nancy Grace investigates mysterious suicide of In 2011, beloved teacher Ellen Greenberg was found dead in her Philadelphia apartment from more than 20 stab wounds when she was just 27 years old. Dr. Marlon Osbourne, a former pathologist with the medical examiners office, initially ruled the death a homicide. Its referred to as a blitz attack, he would later explain. He texted Ellen repeatedly, but got no response, and then forced his way inside the apartment with the help of a building security officer, according to, There was no evidence of a struggle in the kitchen area or anywhere else in the apartment, according to, There was never any reason to suspect suicide in any way shape or form, Sandee, She chickened out [of getting her ears pierced] she didnt like pain, her own pain, her father Joshua Greenberg told, . They hired an expert private investigator who said that there were several areas at the scene that were not investigated thoroughly by police. Eventually he forced himself inside and discovered Greenberg in the home's kitchen, with a 10-inch knife in her chest and more than 20 stab wounds to her chest, abdomen, head and neck, according to the investigation report, which was reviewed by PEOPLE. From the beginning, her family believed the death should be deemed a homicide or undetermined. Ellen Greenberg, left, in an undated family photo. Goldberg sent her increasingly frustrated texts over 22 minutes, according to the MEs investigation report: READ THE DOCUMENTS: Expert reports, autopsy records and more. Fox Nation programs are viewable on-demand and from your mobile device app, but only for Fox Nation subscribers. California residents do not sell my data request. When you separate the wheat (eg, Ellens actual searches) from the chaff (eg, phantom searches which appear on Ellens search history but were not due to direct searches by her), there is no indication of obsession by Ellen over death or suicide. Especially since the security guard, when pressed, admitted he wasn't actually there when Sam Goldberg (fianc) broke down the door. Police on scene treated Ellens death as a suicide. (Tom Brennan). "It seemed rehearsed," Greenberg's cousin Debbie Schwab said in the special regarding the call. Ellen, a 27-year-old elementary school teacher, was found fatally stabbed in her Manayunk apartment in 2011. Re:Did Ellen Greenbergs fianc kill her? So he tried to reach Ellen using his phone. She chickened out [of getting her ears pierced] she didnt like pain, her own pain, her father Joshua Greenberg told Oxygen.com. It is no surprise that the Greenbergs were greatly dissatisfied with the AG's handling of their daughter's matter," their attorney Joseph Podraza, Jr.,said in a statement to the news outlet. or redistributed. Lee concluded that the number and types of wounds and bloodstain patterns observed are consistent with a homicide scene.. Two clean knives were in the sink. The 27-year-old reportedly filled her car up with gas and returned to the Philadelphia apartment she shared with her fianc, Sam Goldberg. New information suggests young fiance found stabbed 20 times did NOT Here are excerpts of the call: Goldberg: "I went . Investigators looked at Ellens laptop computers and found nothing indicative of suicide, the investigation report said. Police said it did. The Greenbergs were devastated. According to McNamee, the neuropathologist who conducted the exam told police that the spinal cord sheath was hit but the cord was not severed. Corin Cesaric is an Associate Editor at PEOPLE. But something struck her as unusual about their conversations. Tim Cooney; Homicide Detective John McNamee; criminal consultant Robert D. Keppel; Gregory McDonald, dean of the School of Health Sciences at the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine; and neuropathologist Lucy Rorke-Adams. Her family has also questioned why she filled up her gas tank before coming home and didnt leave a note indicating that she planned to take her own life. With the MEs ruling, Ellens death became the concern of the Philadelphia Homicide Unit. According to the victim's family, there is a lot of evidence that eliminates suicide as the cause of death. Her fianc, Samuel Goldberg, had returned from the gym to find the door locked. All without a pulse.". It makes no sense, the Greenbergs attorney, Joseph Podraza, told the newspaper. January 26, 2011. If I asked her anything, there would be a long silence. Cooney, the homicide sergeant who supervised the investigation, Detective John McNamee, and other assigned detectives believed the information they developed strengthened the case that Ellen had killed herself. In October 2019, they filed a civil suit against the Philadelphia Medical Examiners Office, along with Dr. Marlon Osbourne, who performed the initial autopsy. To learn more about Ellens case, visit theJustice for Ellen Facebook page. When he returned roughly 30 minutes later, the suite's the swing lock was activated from the inside. She left work early that day due to a blizzard, and stayed inside her apartment at the Venice Lofts, that she shared with her fianc, television producer Sam Goldberg. Ellen Greenberg's parents have been granted a non-jury trial in their lawsuit against the coroner's office over her January 2011 death in her Philadelphia apartment. Its now been picked up by the Chester County District Attorneys Office, who has assigned an investigator and prosecutor to review the Jan. 26, 2011 death. While still in the DAs Office, DAndrea reviewed Ellens entire case file in 2015 at the request of an acquaintance whod heard about the puzzling case. However, I have no recollection of such a case.. Ellen felt overwhelmed at work, but there was never any feeling of suicidal thoughts and she had nothing but good things to say about her fiance, the psychiatrist would later tell investigators. Juniata Park Academy, where Ellen taught first grade, was dismissed early, and she returned to the Venice Lofts apartment she shared with her fiance, Samuel Goldberg, then 28. The Attorney General referred the case in July to the Philadelphia District Attorney, which has now handed the case over to prosecutors in Chester County. On the day Ellen died Jan 26, 2011 a noreaster blanketed the city with snow. View gallery Greenberg is pictured with her parents Sandee and Joshua prior to her death. Facts like Greenberg was holding a knife stabbed in her chest with her left hand even though she was right-handed, and an autopsy revealing the injuries from two different knives but the only weapon recovered made this case interesting. "The new evidence is that from many of her stab wounds, there's no hemorrhage. Ellen Greenberg lawsuit: Parents challenge suicide ruling in This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. She had been stabbed more than 20 times with wounds to the back of her skull, neck and chest. They have been working at PEOPLE for one year. She was searching for medication and weight gain, Joshua said. (Courtesy: Erica Hamilton). Its unlikely, its unusual, but its not impossible.. After initially ruling Ellen's death to be a homicide, the . If it was, it would have rendered her incapacitated and unable to inflict the subsequent wounds on herself, including the final plunge to her chest. Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most your children. She sent out Save the Date cards for her upcoming wedding just days before she died and had no indication of depression or suicidal thoughts. Teacher's Death Was Ruled Suicide But Parents, Citing 20 Stab Wounds, Say She Was Murdered, Pa. Without a report or a bill for her services, I would conclude that I did not see the specimen in question although there is a remote possibility that it was shown to me, she wrote. Joshua Greenberg told CrimeOnline that an attorney the family retained for the case, Joseph Podrazza, uncovered through a technology expert that there was no evidence that Ellen made specific queries about suicide. They filed the civil suit in 2019 against the Philadelphia Medical Examiners Office, along with Dr. Marlon Osbourne. Ellen Greenberg was a 27-year-old first grade teacher at Juniata Park Academy in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. As experts revisit key evidence, Nancy Grace investigates to find answers. Rorke-Adams has no independent recollection of participating in the investigation and we have not found a copy of the report." The question remains whether Ellen Greenberg committed suicide or was murdered, but Grace resolves to get to the bottom of it. Both list suicidal thoughts and behavior as possible side effects. The parents of a Philadelphia teacher found dead in 2011 say that new information uncovered by a technology expert disproves law enforcement findings that she searched online for suicide. In a previous statement issued to WPVI, the Attorney Generals Office said that circumstances beyond our control have created the appearance of a conflict of interest. Facts like Greenberg was holding a knife stabbed in her chest with her left hand even though she was right-handed, and an autopsy revealing the injuries from two different knives but the only . https://www.crimescoop.org/news/ten-years-ago-ellen-greenberg-was-fatally-stabbed-20-times-10-times-in-the-back-of-the-neck-why-is-her-horrific-death-still-being-called-a-suicide, https://www.motheruntitled.com/blog/2017/7/5/caroline-schnay-goldberg-another-mother-her-way. Sam Goldberg, when he . She was happy. New evidence suggested. Crime Stories host Nancy Grace discusses updates in the case of a missing California teen and previews her new show on the mysterious suicide of Ellen Greenberg, now streaming on Fox Nation. . "When we found out that she had died by stabbing there was no way.". The videos also showed no signs of unauthorized access of entrances by anyone around the time of Ellens death, police said. On-the-record interviews include: Josh and Sandra Greenberg; criminal consultant Tom Brennan; former state Attorney General Walter Cohen; former homicide prosecutor Guy DAndrea; forensic pathologist Cyril H. Wecht; Ellen Greenberg friend Debbie Schwab; Greenberg coworker Amy Schwartz; former Venice Lofts property manager Melissa Ware; former Venice Lofts security guard Phil Hanton; former Philadelphia Homicide Capt. Nancy Grace investigates the mysterious 'suicide' of teacher Ellen Greenberg on Fox Nation. Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner and Philadelphia Chief Medical Examiner Sam Gulino declined to comment. On Jan. 29, 2011, a police spokesperson said that despite the homicide ruling, authorities were leaning toward suicide in Ellens case and looking into mental issues she might have had. (Courtesy: Erica Hamilton), TEACHERS PET' SUBJECT CONVICTED OF WIFE'S 1982 MURDER AFTER TRUE CRIME PODCAST SHEDS NEW LIGHT ON COLD CASE. He has seen many stabbing victims without defensive wounds. Greenberg's fianc Sam Goldberg called police on Jan. 26, 2011, to report coming home to find her dead in the kitchen of their Philadelphia apartment, according to court documents. Dr Gary Collins, a supervisor of Osbourne, pointed out "serious and dangerous flaws" in Osbournes autopsy work, which also included missing the obvious signs of strangulation. She was also covered in bruises that pathologists found showed widely varied stages of healing. Listen to a related episode below. That is not the typical pattern of someone who commits suicide through a sharp instrument like that, he said. We've received your submission. media-tech companies with hubs around the world. The parents of a Pennsylvania woman who died of 20 stab wounds are taking the medical examiners office to court for declaring her death a suicide. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. In early 2011, Greenberg's fianc Sam Goldberg returned to their shared residence in the Manayunk neighborhood of Philadelphia from the gym, but couldn't get inside of the apartment because the swing bar lock was in use from the inside. Ellen Greenberg with her fiance Sam Goldberg in an undated family photo (Greenberg family's handout to Fox News Digital) The case was unlike any other. Ellen Greenberg, a first-grade teacher at Juniata Park Academy, was found stabbed to death in her Manayunk apartment on January 26, 2011. PDF NBC10 Philadelphia Did Ellen Greenberg's fianc kill her? - DCUM Weblog Ellen Greenberg's parents vow to keep up fight for justice 12 years All rights reserved. Ellen Greenberg's Death Was Changed To Suicide But Her Parents Didn't Buy It, Investigators initially ruled Ellen Greenbergs death a suicide after concluding there were no signs of forced entry but the Chester County District Attorneys Office has recently announced it is taking a new look at the case, once featured on Oxygens, The Pennsylvania Attorney Generals Office relinquished the case in July after announcing there was an appearance of a conflict of interest, according to. Outside investigators said the damage shown to the lock on Greenberg's apartment door is inconsistent with the report it had been kicked in from the outside. Ellen Greenberg died by 'suicide' with 20 stab wounds. Her - MSN In all my years of experience, and all of the homicides that Ive done, and suicides, Ive never seen anything like this, he said. They ranged from punctures just .2 centimeters deep to the 4-inch final plunge of the still-embedded knife. Tim Cooney would later say. 2023 FOX News Network, LLC. To learn more about the mysterious case, tune in to Oxygens Accident, Suicide or Murder, streaming now. Sam Goldberg told investigators that he left for the gym and returned home to find he was locked out, with the swing lock attached on the inside side of the front door. Notifications can be turned off anytime from browser settings. Goldberg graduated from Temple University and worked in Stamford, Conn., as a producer for NBC Sports. Market data provided by Factset. Josh, 68, a periodontist, and Sandra, 62, a dental hygienist, felt a world away at their home in Harrisburg. It was against policy, the guard told him. A total of 20 stab wounds were found on Ellens body. "Teacher Death Mystery: A Nancy Grace Investigation" is a new show tracing the tragic death of Ellen Greenberg and digging for truth in her mysterious case, streaming now on Fox Nation. You dont need to be a pathologist to have an appreciation for that. She concluded that at least one of the 20 stab wounds on Greenberg occurred postmortem. Legal Statement. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, She had become increasingly anxious, which was unlike her. Berman even noted a smile when she spoke of him, the MEs report said. Scene findings compatible with being staged." The other issue is it wouldnt have been impossible for her to inflict them upon herself. Collins wrote in the department records, "Dr Osbourne, these major discrepancies show an obvious lack of care for your work." The Inquirer also asked two independent experts to review the MEs reports, autopsy photos, and scene photos that were provided by the Greenbergs. Where is Samuel Goldberg now? Whereabouts and Ellen Greenberg - MSN Murder Mixtape 73- The MURDER of Ellen Greenberg Goldberg did not immediately respond to messages seeking comment. Neuropathologist Lyndsey Emery, who was hired by the city of Philadelphia years earlier to evaluate Greenbergs spinal cord, told Greenbergs family attorney that it was significant she had no hemorrhaging, as it strongly suggests she did not have a pulse when she was repeatedly stabbed.